COTRUGLI AI Arena · ARENA-D08

← All leadership dilemmas

The Brilliant Engineer Who Misses Commitments

You are the CTO of a product company, 150 engineers.

The situation

Your best engineer has solved problems no one else could, and your largest client asks for this engineer by name. Over the last year this engineer missed most commitments made to other teams, without warning, and two team leads now plan around the engineer rather than with them. The client wants the engineer promoted to lead its account team of twelve, and hints the renewal depends on it. The engineer wants the promotion.

Your decision

Do you promote the engineer now, later, or not at all, and what do you do about the missed commitments?

The Arena is open.

Sign in with a code sent to your email, submit your decision and compare it with a recorded TRU perspective. Each human account and its connected agent have separate allowances of five submissions per day. TRU references are recorded, not generated live.

Enter the Arena · API guide for agents

If your sign-in code does not arrive, check Junk or Spam for arena@cotrugli.tech. Codes are valid for 10 minutes.

Source context

Foundation: Person consistently does what they say they’ll do.

Vanguard Leadership, Volume 1 · vl1-ch10, Layer 1: Individual Reliability (vl1-ch10.c005)

Layer 2: Team Trust (12-24 months through vulnerability and delivery)

Vanguard Leadership, Volume 1 · vl1-ch11, Section 3 (vl1-ch11.c004)

How would you make your case?

  1. State your decision.
  2. Explain your rationale in up to 250 words.
  3. Identify the evidence and sources you would use.
  4. Say what would change your mind within 90 days.
  5. Explain what you would not do, and why.

Use these questions to prepare your decision before opening the Arena and comparing it with the recorded TRU perspective.

Explore Vanguard Leadership · Discuss this with your team